Types of Environmental Investments in Australia
Environmental investing in Australia is entering a new era, where it is no longer a niche consideration, but rather an integral part of institutional and private portfolios, due to a combination of economic, regulatory and risk management factors. Australia is at the same time a continent highly exposed to climate change, and one of the regions with the largest potential for renewable energy production, as well as a home to emerging carbon and biodiversity markets, regulatory oversight by the Clean Energy Regulator and other factors which shape the environmental investing landscape. As such, the question of which particular types of environmental investments are suitable for consideration in Australia is of active interest to investors, who are seeking to understand the opportunities and risks of the space.
This article provides an overview of the key asset classes which constitute environmental investments, with a particular focus on Australia, as well as considerations specific to the region and relevant for investors.
Understanding Environmental Investments (Context First)
Environmental investments can be generally defined as investments in assets which generate financial returns, as well as contribute to environmental benefits, such as reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, improved resource efficiency, biodiversity conservation and climate resilience.
In Australia, these types of investments can be generally grouped into regulated financial instruments, such as carbon credits and green bonds, natural capital assets, such as land or biodiversity, physical infrastructure, such as renewable energy installations or water treatment facilities, and ESG-focused equities.
1. Renewable Energy Investments
Renewable energy investments generally refer to investments in power generation facilities which utilise solar, wind, hydro or other renewable energy sources.
Australia is exceptionally well-endowed with solar and wind resources, and has a strong policy framework which promotes the development of renewable energy, including the Renewable Energy Target and state-level initiatives, such as Victoria’s Renewable Energy Target. As such, there is a strong case for investments in renewable energy, which can take the form of direct development and ownership of energy generation facilities, participation in renewable energy infrastructure funds, investment in equities of renewable energy companies, or power purchase agreements. At the same time, investors should be aware that returns from such investments are not guaranteed, due to the challenges of the energy sector, such as grid congestion and regulatory risks. While renewable energy assets are generally reliable and long-term, they should not be considered as risk-free.
2. Carbon Market Investments (ACCU and Carbon Credits)
Investments in carbon market instruments in Australia generally take the form of buying and selling Australian Carbon Credit Units, or ACCUs, which are issued under the Emissions Reduction Fund.
Investors can participate in the carbon market in Australia by direct investment in carbon credits, investing in carbon reduction projects or carbon farming initiatives, or through carbon funds managed by the government or private entities. The carbon market in Australia is subject to a strong regulatory framework, and oversight by the Clean Energy Regulator. At the same time, carbon market instruments are generally policy-driven assets, and subject to risks associated with regulatory changes and volatility in carbon prices, which are influenced by supply-demand dynamics, as well as government intervention.
The risks associated with carbon market investments are considerable, including regulatory, liquidity and verification risks, and require a thorough understanding of the carbon market and its intricacies before investing.
3. Natural Capital and Biodiversity Investments
Natural capital and biodiversity investments generally refer to investments in conservation projects, biodiversity credits and related assets, which seek to generate financial returns, as well as environmental benefits, such as habitat protection and restoration, wetland conservation and biodiversity enhancement.
Australia is currently developing its biodiversity markets, with the Nature Repair Markets initiative, which promotes the repair of ecosystems, and allows for biodiversity credits to be issued, which can be purchased by companies and organisations which seek to offset their environmental impact. Biodiversity and natural capital investments are an emerging asset class, which is driven by the demand for ESG-compliant investments, as well as by corporate sustainability commitments. At the same time, this market is highly illiquid, with uncertain returns, and requires long-term commitment from investors.
4. Environmental Infrastructure (Water, Waste and Circular Economy)
Environmental infrastructure investments generally refer to investments in water, waste management and recycling, as well as desalination and other related infrastructure.
Australia is a continent with very limited natural water resources, which makes investments in water infrastructure particularly attractive, due to the combination of regulatory support and long-term demand for water. The same can be said for investments in waste management and recycling, which are also driven by demand, as well as regulatory factors. This category can offer relatively stable returns to investors, due to the guaranteed demand for water and recycling services, although the growth potential of such investments is limited.
5. Green Bonds and Sustainable Fixed Income
Green bonds and other environmentally focused fixed income instruments can be attractive investment options for income-focused investors, due to their safety and stability.
In Australia, green bonds can be issued by the government or private companies, and can take the form of sustainability-linked bonds, which offer enhanced returns to investors. At the same time, investors should be aware that not all green bonds are created equal, and conduct due diligence on a case-by-case basis, analysing the use of proceeds of each particular bond issuance.
6. ESG Equity Investments (Listed Markets)
ESG equity investments refer to investments in publicly-listed companies which adhere to ESG principles, and can include a wide variety of equities, from renewable energy to sustainable materials and clean technology.
While many superannuation funds are beginning to adopt ESG criteria, and ASX-listed companies are generally becoming more transparent about their ESG performance, ESG equity funds are generally diversified, and include companies from a wide variety of sectors, including those which may not necessarily be focused on environmental performance. As such, ESG equity funds should not be considered as purely environmental investments.
7. Climate Tech and Environmental Venture Capital
Climate tech and environmental venture capital generally refer to investments in early-stage technology companies which develop solutions for a wide variety of environmental challenges, from carbon capture to sustainable agriculture and climate data analytics.
Australia has a strong climate tech scene, due to both research performed by local research organisations, such as CSIRO, and the availability of venture capital funding. At the same time, this is a high-risk, high-reward area, which is suitable for sophisticated investors.
8. Sustainable Agriculture and Land-Based Investments
Sustainable agriculture and land-based investments refer to investments in farming and other land-based industries which utilise sustainable practices, such as carbon farming, regenerative agriculture and others.
Sustainable agriculture can generate a wide variety of returns for investors, from yields of agricultural crops to carbon credits. At the same time, agriculture is a high-risk industry due to environmental and market risks.
How These Investment Types Fit Together
A prudent investor would generally not put all of their capital in one category of environmental investments. Instead, they would aim to construct a diversified portfolio, which would include a mix of different asset classes, with varying risk-return characteristics. This would generally include a combination of infrastructure and fixed income investments, as the safest and most reliable category of environmental investments, diversified equity exposure, such as ESG equity funds or renewable energy infrastructure funds, as well as venture capital and carbon market investments, which are much riskier, but offer the potential for higher returns.
Common Mistakes Worth Avoiding
There are several common mistakes which investors tend to make when allocating capital to environmental assets. These include assuming that all environmental investments are inherently safe, which is not the case, as many of them, such as carbon market instruments, are highly volatile. Another mistake is to ignore the importance of regulation, which shapes the performance of many environmental assets, such as carbon credits. Speculative allocations to certain areas, such as carbon markets or biodiversity markets, without sufficient understanding of how they work, can lead to losses for unprepared investors. Assuming that ESG equity funds are purely environmental investments is also a mistake, as many of them are actually quite diversified, and include equities of companies which have little to do with sustainability. Finally, trying to time the market in the environmental investing space is generally unwise.
Key Questions Investors Are Asking
What is the “safest” environmental investment in Australia?
The “safest” environmental investments are generally infrastructure and fixed income instruments, such as green bonds. No investment is ever “safe”, however these have less volatility in terms of price.
What has the highest return potential?
The highest return potential is generally found in venture capital and carbon market instruments, although they also carry the highest risk that investors should be aware of.
Are carbon credits a good investment?
Carbon credits can be a good investment, but they should be approached with caution, due to their volatility.
Is biodiversity investing mature?
Biodiversity investing is still an emerging asset class, with uncertain returns.
Where This Leaves Investors
Environmental investments are set to play an increasingly important role in Australia, due to a combination of regulatory, economic and environmental factors. However, the environmental investing landscape is complex, and many investors find themselves at a loss as to where to begin. The investors who are likely to succeed in this space are the ones who take the time to understand it, rather than get seduced by headlines. A thorough understanding of the regulatory environment, as well as the fundamentals of different environmental asset classes, is crucial in navigating this complex and often intimidating space. Taking a multi-faceted approach, which combines different types of environmental investments, is the best way to mitigate risk and achieve strong risk-adjusted returns.
Australia offers a compelling opportunity for environmental investors, but it is not a market for the unprepared. Approach it with due diligence and a thorough understanding of the space, and you stand to gain significantly. Fail to do your homework, and you stand to lose just as much.
Disclaimer
EnviroInvest Pty Ltd ACN 685 107 957 (“EnviroInvest”) is an Authorised Representative of Daylight Financial Group Pty Ltd ACN 633 984 773 (“DFGPL”) which is the holder of an Australian Financial Services Licence (AFS Licence No. 521404).
Information in this commentary is current as at date prepared unless otherwise stated. However, please bear in mind that investments can go up or down in value, and that past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. For more Important Information please refer to the Disclaimer section of this website.
This communication may contain general financial product advice. It has been prepared without taking into account your personal circumstances, and you should therefore consider its appropriateness in light of your objectives, financial circumstances and needs before acting on it.
If our advice relates to the acquisition or possible acquisition of a particular financial product, you should obtain a copy of and consider the Information Memorandum (IM) or Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) before making any decision.